Academic Papers Need a Letterboxd. Not Another Peer Review.
Academia has a quiet crisis: a vast graveyard of papers that pass every objective check and still say nothing that matters. A new website lets you rate academic papers like albums on RateYourMusic β and the instinctive backlash misses the point entirely. The problem isn’t that subjective ratings are anti-scientific. The problem is that we’ve built a system that can identify correct research but has no mechanism for identifying work that actually moves people.